The Bill of Rights
US constitutional law
The Bill of Rights and the tiers of scrutiny courts use to review laws, for civics, pre-law and first-year constitutional law.
2 study sets · 22 cards · 2 pages of study notes
US constitutional law
Constitutional law · Tiers of scrutiny
This course has two parts that work together: what the rights are, and how courts decide whether a law violates them.
First: The Bill of Rights. Learn what each of the first ten amendments protects, plus the Fourteenth Amendment, which is how most of them came to apply to the states. Civics classes and the citizenship test focus on this part.
Then: Standards of Review. The three tiers of scrutiny are the framework courts use for equal protection and fundamental rights cases. Law students should know, for each tier, what triggers it, what the government must show, and who carries the burden.
For law school, flashcards cover the rules; your casebook covers how they are applied. After learning a rule, write a two-sentence summary of a case that applies it.
Add your own: put your case briefs and outlines in this course. The tutor can quiz you on them and make sets of the holdings.
The Bill of Rights is the first ten amendments to the Constitution, ratified in 1791. At first they limited only the federal government.
Incorporation. After the Civil War, the Fourteenth Amendment (1868) barred states from depriving anyone of life, liberty or property without due process of law. Through a series of cases, the Supreme Court has held that most Bill of Rights protections apply to the states through this Due Process Clause. This happened one right at a time, which is why it is called selective incorporation.
The tiers of scrutiny. When a law is challenged, the level of review decides how hard the court looks, and often decides the outcome.
Rational basis review is the default. The law stands if it is rationally related to any legitimate government interest. The challenger carries the burden, and most laws pass.
Intermediate scrutiny applies to classifications by sex and to some others. The law must be substantially related to an important government interest, and the government carries the burden.
Strict scrutiny applies to classifications by race or national origin, and to laws that burden a fundamental right. The law must be narrowly tailored to a compelling government interest, and the government carries the burden. Most laws reviewed this way are struck down.
In free speech cases, a rule that targets speech because of its content usually gets strict scrutiny. A content-neutral rule about the time, place or manner of speech gets a form of intermediate scrutiny.
How to analyze a question: identify the right or classification involved, decide which tier applies and why, then apply that tier's test to the facts, stating who carries the burden.